A short history of productivity tools
Why some meetings hear more ideas than others.
By the time the first person offers an opinion, everyone else has something to react to. This guide follows several attempts to give people time to form a view before they hear what others think, from written responses to online voting.
Picture an away day in a hotel function room. Twelve people, a flip chart and a facilitator holding a fistful of marker pens. Someone asks what the team should focus on next year. The managing director answers first, and everyone else, give or take, agrees.
By lunch there's a two-by-two grid on the wall. It looks like a group decision. Most of it is one person's view with eleven signatures underneath. This page traces how teams came to decide this way, and what more than a century of research says works instead.
Seventy years of tools
From the planning department to the video call.
"I have two kinds of problems,the urgent and the important."Eisenhower in 1954, quoting a college president he didn't name
- 1954 and 1989
The matrix Eisenhower never drew.
In 1954 Eisenhower quoted an unnamed college president on urgent and important problems. He never drew a grid. Stephen Covey did, 35 years later, in The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People. It was built for one person's to-do list. Put eight people in front of it and you get eight answers, plus whatever the boss says first.
- 1960s and 1970s
Strategy as a department.
Planners gathered the data and wrote the plan. Executives signed it. Everyone else found out afterwards. GE ran 43 business units with a 200-person planning staff. BCG's growth-share matrix arrived in 1970, a grid for an analyst to fill in and a board to read. Nobody voted on it.
- 1980s and 1990s
The backlash.
Jack Welch took over GE in 1981, cut the planners and later replaced the system with five-page playbooks argued over in person. In 1994 Henry Mintzberg argued that planning and strategy are different jobs. The Balanced Scorecard tried to tie the plan to daily work, and away days became the way to bring more people in.
- 2000s and 2010s
The quarter replaces the year.
Agile pushed software into short cycles. The Rockefeller Habits did the same for owner-run firms, and OKRs spread from Intel to Google. They share one idea: ration the list. Three to seven priorities, one owner each. They fixed the calendar. The conversation stayed an open discussion around a table.
- 2020 onwards
The room goes online.
Meetings multiplied and the sticky notes moved to Miro. A 2022 study in Nature found pairs on video came up with fewer ideas, yet picked the best one just as well. Remote work also made anonymous input normal. A poll in the chat collects everyone's view before anyone speaks.
The finding that keeps getting lost
One result, found again and again.
Groups judge better when each person forms a view alone before anyone talks. Researchers have shown it for more than a century. Meetings keep forgetting it.
Plymouth, 1907. Nobody conferred. The middle guess was 1,207 lb. The ox's dressed weight was 1,198 lb.
- 1907
The ox
787 guesses, each made alone. The middle one was less than 1% out.
- 1950s
Delphi at RAND
Experts answer anonymously, see the spread, then revise.
- 1971
Nominal group technique
Write in silence, share one idea each, then vote in private.
- 1985
When different people know different things
A group can spend the meeting repeating information everyone already has, while one person holds the detail that would change the decision. Researchers call this a “hidden profile”.
- 1987
Brainstorming
Waiting your turn to speak blocks thinking. People alone produce more ideas.
- 2011
Social influence
Seeing each other's estimates narrowed the spread. Accuracy stayed flat. Confidence rose.
- 2021
Build a repeatable way to decide
Ask for individual views, compare the answers and make time to ask what led to the differences. This is part of what researchers call “decision hygiene”.
The film version came out in 1957. In 12 Angry Men, Juror 8 is getting nowhere arguing against the other eleven. So he calls a secret ballot and abstains. One "not guilty" comes back. The evidence is exactly what it was ten minutes earlier. Only the way the jurors were asked has changed.
Why it keeps getting lost
Four reasons meetings forget.
Status
The senior person usually speaks first, so everyone after is anchored. Being wrong on your own costs more than being right on your own pays. It even has a name: the HiPPO, the highest paid person's opinion.
Talk feels like teamwork
Silent writing feels like sitting an exam. Open discussion feels lively and inclusive, even when three people do all the talking.
Away days do two jobs
They bond a team and they make decisions. Open discussion is good at the first and weak at the second.
Agreement becomes the goal
Independent input brings disagreement into the open. So the process gets designed to smooth it away.
None of this needs a villain. It's a room of reasonable people responding to their incentives. That's why the fix is a change of procedure. Asking people to speak up leaves the incentives where they were.
What good practice looks like now
Give people time to think before they discuss.
- Everyone writes before anyone speaksA few minutes of silent writing, or a private vote on the list.
- Show the spread before the averageIndependent errors cancel out. Once everyone has heard the boss, the room holds one opinion twelve times over.
- Talk about the disagreement, then vote againEstimate, talk, estimate. The talk is there to surface what only one person knows.
- Keep generating apart from choosingThey use different kinds of attention. Generate in silence, choose together.
- Ration the listThree to seven priorities, each with one named owner. If everything is top right, nothing is.
- Kill the plan before you commit to itA pre-mortem: imagine the plan has failed and write down why, alone, before anyone shares.
- Put the follow-up in the diaryThe priorities live or die in the weekly meeting afterwards.
- One extra rule for senior peopleIf you have to give your view in the room, give it last.
See these rules built into a real agenda.
Four strategy day formats, with timings.Quick answers
Questions people ask.
Who invented the Eisenhower matrix?
Eisenhower supplied the idea and Stephen Covey drew the grid. In 1954 Eisenhower quoted an unnamed college president on urgent and important problems. Covey turned that into a four-box matrix in The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People in 1989.
What's the difference between the Covey matrix and the Eisenhower matrix?
They're the same grid used in different ways. Covey built a philosophy around protecting Quadrant II, the important work with no deadline. The "Eisenhower" version is usually taught as a daily sorting tool.
What are the downsides of the Eisenhower matrix?
It was designed for one person's to-do list. In a group, judgements of urgency and importance tend to be set by whoever speaks first. There's also no direct trial showing the grid improves results.
What academic field studies strategy tools and workshops?
Mainly strategy-as-practice, which Richard Whittington founded in 1996. The evidence on how groups make decisions comes from social psychology and decision science.
What is the best prioritisation method?
The research says the procedure matters more than the grid. Collect independent views first, discuss the disagreements, vote again, keep the list short and give every item one owner.
Sources
- Whittington, R. (1996). Strategy as practice. Long Range Planning 29(5).
- Hodgkinson, G. et al. (2005). UK strategy workshops survey.
- Johnson, G. et al. (2010). The ritualization of strategy workshops. Organization Studies 31(12).
- Abrahamson, E. (1996). Management fashion. Academy of Management Review 21(1).
- Bain & Company. Management Tools & Trends 2017.
- Quote Investigator (2014). What is important is seldom urgent.
- Zhu, M., Yang, Y. and Hsee, C. (2018). The mere urgency effect. Journal of Consumer Research 45(3).
- Harvard Business School case 399-150. GE's two-decade transformation.
- BCG Henderson Institute. The growth share matrix revisited.
- Mintzberg, H. (1994). The fall and rise of strategic planning. Harvard Business Review.
- Kaplan, R. and Norton, D. (1992). The balanced scorecard. Harvard Business Review.
- Manifesto for Agile Software Development (2001).
- Doerr, J. (2018). Measure What Matters.
- Microsoft Work Trend Index 2021, via Business Insider.
- Miro. 2020 review.
- Brucks, M. and Levav, J. (2022). Virtual communication curbs creative idea generation. Nature.
- Wallis, K. (2014). Revisiting Francis Galton's forecasting competition.
- The Delphi method at RAND.
- ATTC Network. A brief history of the nominal group technique.
- Schulz-Hardt, S. et al. Group decision making in hidden profile situations, summarising Stasser and Titus (1985).
- Diehl, M. and Stroebe, W. (1987). Productivity loss in brainstorming groups. JPSP 53(3).
- Lorenz, J. et al. (2011). How social influence can undermine the wisdom of crowd effect. PNAS 108(22).
- Sibony, O. Interview on noise in group decisions.
- TCM. 12 Angry Men (1957).
- Experimentation Platform. Origin of HiPPO.
- Klein, G. (2007). Performing a project premortem. HBR.
- Collins, J. On the premortem evidence.
- Locke, E. and Latham, G. (2002). Building a practically useful theory of goal setting. American Psychologist 57(9).
- Ordóñez, L. et al. (2009). Goals gone wild. Academy of Management Perspectives.
Run your next session the way the research says.
Ask the team to vote on their own, then show the results and start the conversation where people saw things differently.